New York's Convenience of Employer Rule After Zelinsky II: A 2026 Defense Framework for Remote Workers
Last updated: · 13-minute read
If you live in Florida, Texas, New Jersey, or Connecticut and work remotely for a New York employer, New York wants to tax 100 percent of your wages. The mechanism is the "convenience of the employer" rule under 20 NYCRR § 132.18(a). It treats your remote workdays as days worked in New York unless you can prove your employer required the work to be performed at the remote location for the employer's necessity, not your own.
The rule survived its most aggressive constitutional challenge in May 2025 when the New York Tax Appeals Tribunal upheld it in Matter of Zelinsky (Zelinsky II). On June 1, 2026, the Appellate Division heard oral arguments in Zelinsky v. Tax Appeals Tribunal. On July 2, 2026, the Appellate Division rejected Zelinsky's constitutional challenge and upheld the rule. The rule remains in force.
For high-income remote workers with New York employer ties, this is not a theoretical exposure. The New York State Department of Taxation and Finance audits remote work arrangements aggressively. The rule applies whether the employer's New York office is closed, whether the employee has never set foot in New York during the tax year, or whether the work could be performed from anywhere. The only defense that holds up is documentary evidence that the remote location satisfies New York's narrow "bona-fide-employer-office" exception. Most remote workers do not satisfy it. Some can. The question is which group you are in and what documentation establishes the defense.
- NY's convenience rule under 20 NYCRR § 132.18(a) sources 100% of NY employer wages to NY unless the bona-fide-employer-office exception is met.
- Zelinsky II (May 15, 2025) upheld the rule even for the COVID period when Executive Order 202.8 prohibited the taxpayer from entering NY.
- Zelinsky v. Tax Appeals Tribunal (CV-25-1156) was decided by the Appellate Division, Third Department on July 2, 2026, which upheld the rule.
- The bona-fide-employer-office defense (TSB-M-06(5)I) requires six documented elements to hold up in audit; partial satisfaction generally fails.
- NJ and CT have reciprocal convenience rules and resident credits, but the credits don't always fully offset NY's tax.
This article walks through the post-Zelinsky II posture of the rule, the bona-fide-employer-office exception that controls every defense, the documentation framework that holds up in a New York residency audit, the resident-state credits available in New Jersey and Connecticut, and what high-income remote workers should do before they file their next nonresident New York return.
The Convenience Rule in 2026
The convenience of the employer rule is set forth in 20 NYCRR § 132.18(a). The rule applies to nonresidents who perform services partly within and partly without New York for a New York employer. By default, every day worked from outside New York is treated as a day worked in New York for income-sourcing purposes, unless the work was performed outside New York for the employer's necessity. The taxpayer carries the burden of establishing that the remote location satisfies the employer-necessity standard.
In May 2025, the New York Tax Appeals Tribunal upheld the rule in Matter of Zelinsky, DTA Nos. 830517 and 830681[1]. The case involved Edward Zelinsky, a Connecticut-resident law professor at Cardozo School of Law in Manhattan. Zelinsky sought a refund for 2019 and 2020. The 2020 year was particularly significant because Governor Cuomo's Executive Order 202.8 had closed his New York office and prohibited non-essential workers from entering the state. The Tribunal nonetheless held that the rule applied. New York was entitled to source 100 percent of his Cardozo wages to New York, including for days when New York law forbade him from working in New York.
The Tribunal rejected three constitutional arguments. It rejected the Commerce Clause challenge, holding that the rule applies only to wages from New York employers and that any double taxation arises from Connecticut's own credit limitations, not New York's scheme. It rejected the Due Process challenge, holding that Zelinsky availed himself of New York's economic market through his New York employer even when working entirely outside the state. It rejected the argument that Wynne and MeadWestvaco had eroded the 2003 Zelinsky v. Tax Appeals Tribunal precedent.
Zelinsky appealed to the New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division, Third Department. Oral arguments were heard on June 1, 2026. The case is Zelinsky v. Tax Appeals Tribunal, No. CV-25-1156[2]. During oral argument, Justice Justin O. Corcoran voiced skepticism about "the future viability of the convenience-of-employer test given the changes in the remote work environment." The Appellate Division nonetheless upheld the rule on July 2, 2026. Until the decision is issued, and unless reversed on appeal, the rule continues to apply in full force.
The October 2025 decision in Matter of Hoff (DTA No. 850209), though a domicile case rather than a convenience rule case, signals the same New York posture[3]. In Hoff, a couple who had executed a Florida Declaration of Domicile, obtained Florida driver's licenses, and registered to vote in Florida nonetheless failed to change their domicile from New York to Florida. The Tribunal applied the clear-and-convincing-evidence standard and found that the formal steps did not overcome continued New York business ties and personal connections. The takeaway across both Zelinsky II and Hoff is that New York rarely concedes the source of income or the source of domicile when the taxpayer's connection to New York remains economically meaningful.
Does New York Tax Your Remote Workday?
Decision logic for a nonresident remote worker employed by a New York employer (2026).
Decision logic for the 2026 convenience rule under 20 NYCRR § 132.18(a). For knowledge workers whose home office does not contain specialized facilities, the secondary-factor analysis controls. Partial satisfaction of the bona-fide-employer-office framework generally results in full NY sourcing.
The Bona-Fide-Employer-Office Exception
The only operational exception to the convenience rule for high-income remote workers is the bona-fide-employer-office test articulated by the New York State Department of Taxation and Finance in TSB-M-06(5)I[7]. Under this test, a remote work location is treated as a bona fide employer office, and days worked there are sourced to the remote location rather than to New York, only if certain factors are met.
The TSB-M-06(5)I framework is structured around a primary factor and two sets of secondary factors. The primary factor is whether the home office contains or is near specialized facilities. If the home office is the only practical location from which to perform the services because of specialized equipment, library, or facilities not available at the employer's office, the bona-fide-office test is satisfied at the primary-factor level.
For most knowledge workers, the primary factor is not met. The secondary factors then control. The secondary factors include whether the home office is a requirement or condition of employment, whether the employer has a bona fide business purpose for the employee's home office, and whether the employee performs core duties from the home office that cannot be performed at the employer's New York office. The framework also examines whether the employer reimburses home office expenses, whether the employer mails business correspondence to the home office, whether the employer's letterhead or business cards list the home office as an employer location, and whether the home office is used to meet with clients or patients of the employer.
The standard a remote worker has to meet, as articulated in the Tribunal's Zelinsky II analysis and in earlier cases, is high. The bona-fide-office exception is the rule's narrowest carve-out, designed to apply to scientists, certain engineers, and specialists whose work genuinely cannot be performed in the employer's main location. It is not designed for, and does not generally apply to, knowledge workers who choose to work from home for personal reasons that the employer accommodates.
What the Bona-Fide-Office Defense Looks Like in Practice
For a high-income remote worker who wants to defend a non-New York-sourced position on a nonresident return, the documentation framework that holds up has six elements.
Element 1: Employment contract identifying the remote location as primary
The employment contract or offer letter must specifically identify the remote location as the employee's primary work location. Language that the employee "may work remotely as needed" or that the company offers flexible work arrangements does not satisfy the test. The employment document needs to identify the remote location as a place where the employer requires the work to be performed.
Element 2: Documented employer business necessity for the remote location
This is the load-bearing element of the defense. Generic remote-work policies do not create employer necessity. The employer needs to articulate, in writing, why the work must be performed at the specific remote location. Examples that have been accepted include: the employee's expertise is required at a client site in the remote state, the employer is establishing a market presence in the remote state and needs the employee to develop it, or the employer's other regional operations require the employee to be physically present in the remote state.
Element 3: Employer correspondence directed to the remote location
Employer business correspondence must be sent to the remote location. Mail addressed to the New York office that is then forwarded does not satisfy the test. The employer must direct primary business correspondence to the remote location as an established employer site.
Element 4: Remote location listed on employer marketing materials
The employer's letterhead, business cards, website, and internal directories must list the remote location as a business location of the employer. If the employer's website lists only the New York office and the remote employee's address does not appear anywhere as an employer location, the defense weakens substantially.
Element 5: Ongoing employer reimbursement of home office expenses
Employer reimbursement of home office expenses must be documented and ongoing. Reimbursement signals that the employer treats the location as its own. A one-time stipend at the start of remote work does not establish ongoing employer treatment.
Element 6: Remote location used for client or partner meetings
The remote location must be used to meet with the employer's clients, customers, or partners. The location must function as an employer office that third parties can identify as such, not merely as a home where the employee performs work alone.
Audit defense is binary in this respect: a defense that satisfies five of six elements generally does not win; the defense that satisfies all six does.
Schedule a Convenience Rule Defense Assessment
For high-income remote workers with NY employer ties, the time to assess the bona-fide-employer-office defense is before the return is filed, not after. Our team can map your specific employment arrangement against the six-element framework.
Book a CallWhat Does Not Help (Even If You Think It Should)
The Tribunal's reasoning in Zelinsky II clarified several arguments that do not defeat the convenience rule, even where the facts seem compelling.
The fact that the employer's New York office was closed, including under government order, does not establish employer necessity for the remote location. Zelinsky II directly addressed this for the 2020 tax year, when Governor Cuomo's Executive Order 202.8 prohibited non-essential workers from entering New York. The Tribunal held that the closure made the work physically impossible to perform in New York but did not make the remote location a bona-fide employer office. The work was deemed to be performed in New York for sourcing purposes notwithstanding the prohibition on entering the state.
The fact that the employer permits or encourages remote work does not establish employer necessity. The Tribunal's analysis distinguishes between an employer permitting remote work as a convenience to the employee, which is the entire scope of the rule, and an employer requiring remote work because it cannot be performed in New York. Hiring policies that allow flexible work, work-from-anywhere arrangements, or "remote-first" cultures are convenience-to-employee policies and do not establish employer necessity.
The fact that the employee's home state imposes its own income tax, and the resulting double-tax burden, does not establish unconstitutional taxation. The Tribunal in Zelinsky II held that double taxation arises from the resident state's credit limitations, not from New York's sourcing rule. New York is entitled to tax the wages it sources to New York regardless of what Connecticut, New Jersey, or any other resident state does with its credit for taxes paid to New York.
The fact that the employee never set foot in New York during the tax year does not defeat sourcing. Sourcing under the convenience rule is based on the legal characterization of the work, not on physical presence. A nonresident employee who performed zero days in New York during 2026 can still have 100 percent of New York employer wages sourced to New York if the convenience rule applies.
Resident-State Credits: New Jersey and Connecticut
For New Jersey and Connecticut residents working remotely for New York employers, the resident-state credit landscape has shifted in the past two years.
New Jersey enacted P.L. 2023, c. 125 on July 21, 2023, establishing a reciprocal convenience-of-employer rule effective for tax year 2023 and forward. Under New Jersey's reciprocal rule, NJ applies its own convenience-of-employer sourcing to nonresidents of NJ from convenience-rule states (NY, DE, NE). For NJ residents working for NY employers, this means NJ has structured a refundable credit mechanism designed to recover revenue lost to NY through resident credits. The legislation also earmarked $35 million in grants to incentivize companies to assign NJ-based employees to NJ locations[4].
Connecticut enacted its reciprocal convenience rule in 2019 and refined it through legislation passed by the General Assembly on June 4, 2025. CT's rule applies to nonresidents of CT only when the nonresident's resident state has a convenience rule of its own (primarily NY, but also DE, NE, and PA). For CT residents working for NY employers, CT permits a credit for income tax paid to NY under NY's convenience rule, but the credit is subject to Conn. Gen. Stat. § 12-704 limitations, which the Zelinsky II Tribunal specifically noted does not provide a full offset in all cases[5].
The practical effect for high-income remote workers is this: if you are a CT resident working for an NY employer, you may face partial double taxation on the income NY sources to itself, because CT's credit does not fully eliminate the NY tax on income that CT also taxes as resident income. If you are an NJ resident working for an NY employer, your credit position is somewhat better, but the convenience-rule double-tax exposure has not been eliminated. The states are litigating around the edges of this problem; the structural solution has not been delivered.
For high-income remote workers who anticipate audit exposure, the resident-state credit landscape is one variable among several. The primary planning lever remains whether the bona-fide-employer-office defense can be established on the facts. If it can, no resident-state credit is needed because New York does not source the income to itself. If it cannot, the resident-state credit becomes the residual mitigation.
What This Means for High-Income Remote Workers in 2026
For households earning over $400,000 with one or both wage-earners working remotely for New York employers from FL, TX, NJ, CT, or another non-NY state, the convenience rule's exposure is large enough that a documented audit-defense posture is the only responsible position. The exposure scales with income. A $1.5 million household with primary earnings sourced to NY under the convenience rule faces NY tax of approximately $130,000 to $140,000 on income that the household believes should not have been NY-sourced. Even after resident-state credits, the residual NY tax exposure is meaningful.
The work begins with an honest assessment of whether the employment arrangement satisfies the six-element bona-fide-employer-office framework. If it does, the documentation file is built and the return is filed taking the non-NY-sourced position with substantiation. If it does not, the household has three remaining strategies: restructure the employment arrangement so that the bona-fide-office test can be satisfied prospectively, accept NY sourcing and optimize the resident-state credit position, or pursue a domicile or employment-relocation change that removes the NY employer connection entirely.
None of these strategies is a partial measure. The convenience rule does not allow for compromise outcomes; sourcing is either to NY or it is not. The audit defense, when built properly, is binary. The household that walks into a NY residency audit with five of six bona-fide-office elements satisfied generally does not win; the household with all six does.
The July 2026 Appellate Division Decision
The Appellate Division, Third Department heard oral arguments on June 1, 2026, and on July 2, 2026 it rejected Zelinsky's challenge. The court held that his employer did not require him to work from Connecticut, so his remote workdays were for his own convenience and his wages were New York-source, including for 2020 pandemic days. A further appeal to the New York Court of Appeals is possible.
The relevant planning takeaway is that the rule applies as we describe it for tax year 2026 and for any pre-2026 years still open under audit. A future decision by the Appellate Division, by the Court of Appeals, or by the U.S. Supreme Court could change the analysis. None of those decisions exist yet. The 2026 return must be filed under the rule as it currently stands.
We work with high-income remote workers on the convenience rule framework as part of our tax planning practice. The work typically begins with an assessment of the employment structure, the documentation file, and the household's specific residency posture, followed by either a defense plan or a prospective restructuring of the employment arrangement.
Ready to Build Your 2026 Convenience Rule Defense?
The introductory call with our Client Coordinator helps determine fit. From there, our Tax Planning Team walks through the six-element defense framework against your specific employment arrangement.
Schedule a ConsultationFrequently Asked Questions About NY's Convenience Rule
What is New York's convenience of the employer rule?
New York's convenience of the employer rule, codified at 20 NYCRR § 132.18(a), treats every workday a nonresident performs outside New York for a New York employer as a day worked in New York for income-sourcing purposes, unless the work was performed outside New York for the employer's necessity rather than the employee's convenience. The rule means that a nonresident working remotely for a New York employer typically has 100 percent of New York employer wages sourced to New York, even if zero workdays were physically performed in New York during the year. The exception is the bona-fide-employer-office framework articulated in TSB-M-06(5)I, which is met only in narrow circumstances.
Did Zelinsky II change the convenience rule?
No. The May 15, 2025 Tax Appeals Tribunal decision in Matter of Zelinsky (DTA Nos. 830517 and 830681) upheld the rule against constitutional challenge, including for the COVID period when New York Executive Order 202.8 prohibited non-essential workers from entering the state. The Tribunal rejected Commerce Clause, Due Process, and Wynne-based challenges. The Appellate Division, Third Department upheld that result on July 2, 2026. Unless a higher court reverses, the rule applies in full force.
How can I avoid New York tax on remote-work days under the convenience rule?
The defense is the bona-fide-employer-office framework set out in TSB-M-06(5)I. Six elements work together: the employment contract identifying the remote location as the primary work location, documented business necessity for the remote location (not employee convenience), employer correspondence directed to the remote location, the remote location listed on employer marketing materials, employer reimbursement of home office expenses, and the remote location being used for client meetings. Partial satisfaction of these elements is generally insufficient; the audit defense is binary.
Does it matter if I never physically worked in New York?
No. The convenience rule sources income based on the legal characterization of the work, not physical presence. A nonresident employee who performed zero days in New York during the tax year can still have 100 percent of New York employer wages sourced to New York if the convenience rule applies and the bona-fide-employer-office exception is not satisfied. This was confirmed in Zelinsky II for the 2020 tax year, when Executive Order 202.8 prohibited the taxpayer from entering New York.
What about New Jersey or Connecticut residents who work for New York employers?
Both states have enacted reciprocal convenience-of-employer rules and provide resident credits for taxes paid to New York, but the credit mechanisms do not always fully offset the New York tax. New Jersey's reciprocal rule was enacted in P.L. 2023, c. 125. Connecticut's was enacted in 2019 and refined by 2025 General Assembly legislation. For New Jersey and Connecticut residents working remotely for New York employers, partial double taxation is common when the resident-state credit is subject to limitations under the resident state's own credit statute (e.g., Conn. Gen. Stat. § 12-704). The bona-fide-employer-office defense remains the primary planning lever; the resident-state credit is the residual mitigation.
References
- Matter of Edward A. and Doris Zelinsky, DTA Nos. 830517 and 830681 (N.Y.S. Tax Appeals Tribunal May 15, 2025). dta.ny.gov/pdf/decisions/830517_%20830681.dec.pdf
- Zelinsky v. Tax Appeals Tribunal, No. CV-25-1156 (N.Y. App. Div. 3d Dep't July 2, 2026) (upholding the convenience rule).
- Matter of John J. Hoff and Kathleen Ocorr-Hoff, DTA No. 850209 (N.Y.S. Tax Appeals Trib. Oct. 9, 2025). Domicile case; cited here as parallel evidence of New York's aggressive nonresident audit posture.
- New Jersey P.L. 2023, c. 125 (enacted July 21, 2023). New Jersey Division of Taxation, Convenience of the Employer Sourcing Rule Enacted for Gross Income Tax. nj.gov/treasury/taxation/conveniencerule.shtml
- Conn. Gen. Stat. § 12-711(b)(2)(C) (convenience of employer rule for nonresidents) and § 12-704 (resident credit for taxes paid to other states), as refined by Connecticut General Assembly legislation enacted June 4, 2025.
- 20 NYCRR § 132.18(a). The controlling regulation defining the New York convenience of the employer rule.
- New York State Department of Taxation and Finance, Technical Services Bureau Memorandum TSB-M-06(5)I (May 15, 2006). Bona-fide-employer-office framework.
General Disclaimer. This article is provided by Nashional Tax Planning for general informational and educational purposes only. It does not constitute tax, legal, accounting, investment, or other professional advice, and it does not establish a professional-client relationship between you and Nashional Tax Planning, Jeff Nash, Benjamin Trageser, or any contributor. The information has not been prepared with reference to any particular taxpayer's situation. New York tax law, regulations, Tribunal decisions, and Appellate Division case law change frequently. Portions of this article may become outdated, particularly with the Zelinsky v. Tax Appeals Tribunal Appellate Division decision of July 2, 2026 and any further appeal.
Before acting on any strategy, position, or planning idea described here, you should consult a qualified tax professional who has reviewed your specific facts and circumstances. No specific tax result, savings amount, refund, or audit outcome is promised, projected, predicted, or guaranteed. Outcomes depend on individual facts, applicable federal and state law, timing, and factors outside our control.
No Reliance / No Liability. This article is provided "as is" without warranties of any kind, whether express or implied, including warranties of accuracy, completeness, timeliness, merchantability, or fitness for a particular purpose. To the fullest extent permitted by applicable law, Nashional Tax Planning and its contributors disclaim any and all liability for losses or damages, direct or indirect, arising from your use of, or reliance on, the information in this article. Any examples, hypothetical scenarios, or projected outcomes referenced are illustrative or general only and should not be interpreted as a typical, expected, or guaranteed result for any specific taxpayer.
Audit Risk Notice. The New York convenience of the employer rule is among the most aggressively audited positions on a nonresident New York income tax return. The bona-fide-employer-office defense described in this article carries independent substantiation and documentation requirements that must be satisfied before the position is taken on a return. Nothing in this article substitutes for the documentation analysis that a qualified New York-licensed CPA or attorney should perform on a taxpayer's specific facts before the position is claimed.
State Notice — Texas. This firm is not a CPA firm and these services are not regulated by the Texas State Board of Public Accountancy. Tax planning services delivered by Jeff Nash are provided in his individual professional capacity as a Texas-licensed Certified Public Accountant. This notice is included pursuant to Texas Administrative Code Title 22, Section 501.81(c).
Multi-State Practice Notice. Nashional Tax Planning provides tax planning services in multiple U.S. jurisdictions. Out-of-state services are delivered under applicable practice-privilege rules. Nothing in this article should be construed as the practice of public accountancy in any state where the contributing practitioner is not licensed or registered. Residents of New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, Pennsylvania, Delaware, and Nebraska facing convenience-of-employer rule issues should consult a state-licensed CPA or attorney admitted in the relevant state for matters governed by that state's tax law. Convenience-of-employer rules vary materially across states; nothing in this article addresses the rules of Delaware, Nebraska, Oregon, or Pennsylvania in detail.
Enrolled Agent Notice. Where Benjamin Trageser, Enrolled Agent, is referenced, "Enrolled Agent" means a federally-authorized tax practitioner empowered by the U.S. Department of the Treasury to represent taxpayers before the Internal Revenue Service. Enrolled Agents are not employees of, nor certified by, the Internal Revenue Service.
Investment Advisory Notice. Jeff Nash is an Investment Advisor Representative. Nothing in this article constitutes investment advice, a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold any security, or an offer to provide investment advisory services. Investment advisory services, where offered, are provided pursuant to a separate written agreement and are subject to applicable federal and state securities regulations.
Forward-Looking Statements. Statements in this article that describe future tax law, future planning outcomes, IRS or state administrative interpretations, or future regulatory and judicial developments are forward-looking and are based on information available as of the date noted below. Actual outcomes may differ materially. The July 2, 2026 Appellate Division decision in Zelinsky v. Tax Appeals Tribunal (No. CV-25-1156), any further appeals, and any U.S. Supreme Court review could modify the framework described.
Last updated: June 10, 2026.


